Although having a sunroof or moonroof can give the feeling of being in a convertible, they provide more security than a canvas convertible top, according to MotorTrend. Even when they are up, canvas tops make the vehicle more accessible to thieves because they can be slashed, says FindandFundMyCar.com.

Government crash-test results have shown that the effect of a sunroof is insignificant to the overall strength of the roof, explains Consumer Reports. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) also rates vehicles for roof strength as part of its vehicle ratings – you can check your specific car’s rating on their vehicle ratings page.

On the other hand, leaks are one of the most common complaints about moonroofs and sunroofs, and can be caused by debris clogging the drainage system, says YourMechanic.com. This can be especially true if you have an aftermarket moonroof or sunroof installed.

Another drawback of the sunroof and moonroof is that they add noticeable mass at the top of the vehicle, which raises the center of gravity — which in turn can affect handling, says MotorTrend.